Book Response: Reforming Criminal Justice by Matt Martens

by | Nov 7, 2023

Matt Martens is a man on a mission. He’s in his fifties and is a partner at one of the most prestigious law firms in the country. He has worked for the Department of Justice. He has multiple graduate degrees and is working on another. He has more drive and ambition than most and has a sharp mind honed by years of experience and research. But what stands out most about him is his focus. 

Martens is laser-focused on helping Christians love our neighbors. He has a long and successful career as both a prosecutor and defense attorney and is convinced that the criminal justice system in our country is in need of reform. He makes that case convincingly in his forthcoming book, Reforming Criminal Justice: A Christian Proposal (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2023). 

The key to this book is in the subtitle. It’s explicitly, unapologetically Christian. Martens makes no prudential or political argument. He makes the case that Christians must love our neighbors. All of them. And that should be our guiding ethic when we consider the criminal justice system. We should love the criminally accused, the criminally convicted, and the criminally victimized. We should do this, Martens argues, because we are commanded to do so by God. 

The research in this book stands out. There are a lot of footnotes. As Martens explains the history of criminal justice in our country, he does so as someone who knows what he’s talking about. This history can be upsetting at times. I had to set the book down at several points to take a break, and I read hard things for a living. Martens shares details of several stories of the wrongly accused and imprisoned. He shares about people who have been exonerated after losing decades of their lives behind bars. He explains abuses and failures in the system which create these unjust outcomes and explains why it will be difficult to change the system. 

Despite all that, this book is surprisingly hopeful, which should not be surprising given how Christian it is. Martens knows that while human judges may fail us, the Judge of all the Earth shall do right. 

I found this book so helpful because I have been content to get my opinions on criminal justice from pundits and commentators. I assume some of you have as well. I have never considered how to have a uniquely Christian approach to criminal justice reform. In that sense, Martens’ book is a breath of fresh air. 

He deals with themes like accuracy, due process, and proportionality, drawing on centuries of Christian ethics. He points out elements of the criminal justice system that price efficiency over accuracy and other failures to love our neighbors. 

Something that stands out is how Martens refrains from binding the conscience of his readers. He makes the case for and against certain practices and procedures. But does not say, “A Christian approach to criminal justice must involve this specific list of reforms.” Instead, he offers advice to think differently, speak differently, and vote differently, leaving the readers to sort out the specifics. 

As I wrote in the beginning of this reflection, Matt is on a mission. He is focused at this point in his life on helping Christians to think and pray about criminal justice reform. He’s not only focused on attorneys and law enforcement officials. He wants Christians in all walks of life to care about this for the sake of loving our neighbors. I interviewed him recently for our podcast, and after the mics were off, he told me that he’s spent every spare moment for the last two years thinking about how to love his neighbors. It shows. Love is the motivation behind this book and what he hopes to impart to his readers. I pray he is successful.

 

Prayer Requests:

  1. Pray for this book, that it is widely read and that it convinces Christians to love all our neighbors. 
  2. Pray for those involved in the criminal justice system as law enforcement, attorneys, judges, and jurors. Pray that they would fear God and love their neighbors. 
  3. Pray for those currently in the criminal justice system who are criminally convicted and criminally accused. Pray that they would receive true justice and that they would seek Christ. 
  4. Pray for the criminally victimized, that they would receive justice and be comforted by Christ.

Recent POdcasts

The Incarnation with Fred Sanders

The Incarnation with Fred Sanders

Merry Christmas from United? We Pray. For this very special Christmas episode, we sit down with Dr. Fred Sanders to talk about the Incarnation of Christ. What does it mean that Jesus came to Earth as a baby boy? What does it mean that he came as a Jewish baby boy with...

read more
Ethnic Sins with Shai Linne

Ethnic Sins with Shai Linne

 Shai Linne joins us again today to talk about his section in The New Reformation (Moody, 2020) in which he outlines various ethnic sins which commonly fall under the heading "racism." By differentiating these kinds of sins, Shai gives us tools to deal with them from...

read more
The Evangelical Imagination with Karen Swallow Prior

The Evangelical Imagination with Karen Swallow Prior

It was an honor to be joined by Dr. Karen Swallow Prior, author of the new book The Evangelical Imagination: How Stories, Images, & Metaphors Created a Culture in Crisis. Dr. Prior has keen insight into the role our imaginations play in creating assumptions about...

read more

Upcoming Events

Isaac-Adams-United-We-Pray-speaking-at-an-event

Click Here to View Now

Recent Articles

WHY I STUDY BLACK HISTORY

WHY I STUDY BLACK HISTORY

Black History Month sprang out of African American celebrations of Abraham Lincoln’s and Frederick Douglass’s February birthdays. “Negro History Week” began in February 1926 to recognize African American contributions to society and raise awareness of the prejudice...

read more
MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 2)

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 2)

Paul preached patience when dealing with people sidelined in life. Regardless of whether individuals remained out of the battle due to laziness, apathy, fear, or brokenness, he said all of them must be treated with patience. We don’t care much for patience these days....

read more
MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

This is the arresting and dominant fact about modern social discussion; that the quarrel is not merely about the difficulties, but about the aim. We agree about the evil; it is about the good that we should tear each other’s eyes out. – G.K. Chesterton, 1910 Over 113...

read more

We’d love to hear what you think about this article. Submit your feedback by clicking here to contact us.

Author

  • Austin Suter

    Austin is the executive director and editor for U?WP. He is a husband, father and seminary student at RTS Charlotte. Austin is a member at Iron City Church in Birmingham, AL. @amsuter

Related Articles

WHY I STUDY BLACK HISTORY

WHY I STUDY BLACK HISTORY

Black History Month sprang out of African American celebrations of Abraham Lincoln’s and Frederick Douglass’s February birthdays. “Negro History Week” began in February 1926 to recognize African American contributions to society and raise awareness of the prejudice...

read more

Stay Connected