United We Pray Loading and Newsletter Logo
Loading ...

Should I Read Books by Slaveholders?

by | Apr 14, 2020

In part one of this series, Should I Read Books by Slaveholders?, Isaac wrote about processing the failings of our historical heroes. This piece takes a step further back to ask whether or not we should be reading or revering people in the first place if we know them to have been racists.

I’ll lay my cards on the table early–I think Christians have freedom to read or not read, and we should give each other space to make those decisions without judging each others’ motivations. In other words, we’re in the realm of Romans 14 freedom, not “thou shalt/ shalt not.”

 

Scripture is Our Only Must-Read

My favorite historic confession of faith begins with these words: “The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving knowledge, faith, and obedience.”[1] Christians need to read the Bible. We know this. But that word “only” is really important. Only Scripture is perfect. Only Scripture is essential.

What this means is that every Christian author or teacher since the Scriptures has been, in a sense, dispensable. People get saved and mature into obedience without reading or hearing any one person other than Jesus.

I do not mean to say that every Christian is an island unto themselves–alone with the Scriptures–free to believe whatever they decide. I just quoted a 400 year old confession! I think the wisdom of saints through the ages is really important.

What I want to free us from is thinking any one person within any theological tradition is essential. Paul chastises the Corinthians for this kind of thinking: “One of you says, ‘I belong to Paul,’ or ‘I belong to Apollos,’ or ‘I belong to Cephas,’ or ‘I belong to Christ.’ Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized in Paul’s name?” (I Corinthians 1:12-13).

 

Other Books to Read, or Not

If a Christian, in good conscience, decides that he or she cannot read Jonathan Edwards because he was a slave-owner, that’s a legitimate decision. We should affirm such decisions even if we’ve made different ones. Giving racism a “yeah, but” to hold up our heroes harms the unity of Christ’s body. At the same time, a brother or sister might keep Edwards on the shelf and that doesn’t make them a racist.

Every one of us makes these calculations to a certain extent. Every Christian teacher is flawed. When do those flaws mean that a teacher’s work should be thrown out? I’ve already argued that there isn’t a perfect formula, so we should give each other room. But you might find the list of qualifications for pastors in I Timothy 3:1-7 helpful. Usually, if I’m going to read, and certainly if I’m going to quote someone, I think they should pass this test.

Let’s try to do this consistently. Let’s not rush to point out the moral flaws of Martin Luther King, Jr. as disqualifying without applying the same process to George Whitfield. Even if we reach different conclusions between ourselves, we will understand each other better if we acknowledge the validity of the approach.

As I consider how to make such judgments about teachers, the conclusion I keep coming back to is that I’m so grateful for a perfect Judge. I can’t weigh the spiritual condition of someone who had great theology but thought racism was fine. God can and will. I pray that each of us will come to know this God and press on towards greater obedience.

 


  • [1]1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith, 1:1.

 


Prayer Requests:

  1. As we encounter flawed teachers, pray against a pharisaical attitude, especially as faithful brothers and sisters reach differing conclusions.
  2. Lament before God the presence of racism in His churches.
  3. Pray to the One who can change hearts that His people would truly be as they are–one new humanity in Christ.

 

Recent POdcasts

Raising the Next Generation

Raising the Next Generation

Raising the Next Generation | Parenting Few things are as difficult as parenting. If you desire to raise your kids to be agents of unity among God's people, it is even harder. Josh Chatman, host of the Train 'em Up podcast stops by to talk about parenting. Austin and...

read more
Biblical Theology: Major Prophets | God’s faithfulness

Biblical Theology: Major Prophets | God’s faithfulness

Biblical Theology: Major Prophets | God's faithfulness Today, Adrianna and Austin are exploring the major prophets and seeing God's plan for His people from all nations. While these books occur in the context immediately preceding and during the Exile, God's...

read more
Biblical Theology: The Exile | Interracial Marriage

Biblical Theology: The Exile | Interracial Marriage

Biblical Theology: The Exile | Interracial Marriage What does the Bible say about interracial marriage? Adrianna Anderson and Austin Suter continue this exploration of Biblical Theology as we look at Daniel, Esther, Nehemiah, and Ezra. These books represent the exile...

read more

Upcoming Events

Isaac-Adams-United-We-Pray-speaking-at-an-event

Click Here to View Now

Recent Articles

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

This is the arresting and dominant fact about modern social discussion; that the quarrel is not merely about the difficulties, but about the aim. We agree about the evil; it is about the good that we should tear each other’s eyes out. – G.K. Chesterton, 1910 Over 113...

read more
Editor’s Pick: Our Favorite Episodes of 2022

Editor’s Pick: Our Favorite Episodes of 2022

This was a big year for our ministry. We need to thank you for sharing this podcast with your family and friends, because our subscriber base has grown tremendously this year. We were blessed to have some great guests and episodes this year. I wanted to share a few...

read more
Thanksgiving Special 2022

Thanksgiving Special 2022

Christians should be, by nature, thankful people. We understand that we were created by God, in His image, with the capacity to know Him and love others created in His image. As we all celebrate the day of Thanksgiving this week, I wanted to offer a specific word of...

read more

We’d love to hear what you think about this article. Submit your feedback by clicking here to contact us.

Author

  • Austin-Suter-United-We-Pray bio photo

    Austin is the executive director and editor for U?WP. He is a husband, father and seminary student at RTS Charlotte. Austin is a member at Iron City Church in Birmingham, AL. @amsuter

    View all posts

Related Articles

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

MLK DAY SPECIAL: BE PATIENT WITH THEM ALL (PART 1)

This is the arresting and dominant fact about modern social discussion; that the quarrel is not merely about the difficulties, but about the aim. We agree about the evil; it is about the good that we should tear each other’s eyes out. – G.K. Chesterton, 1910 Over 113...

read more

Stay Connected